An activity is regulated in the UK if it: (a) is of a specified kind that (b) relates to a specified investment or, where it relates to a specified activity, property of any kind and (c) is carried on by way of business (d) in the UK. The specified activities and investments are set out in the RAO.
A broad range of activities are set out in the RAO, including the following:
As noted above, for an activity to be a regulated activity, it must be "carried on by way of business." The term "by way of business" is not defined in FSMA or the RAO, but the FCA has issued guidance on "the business test" in its Perimeter Guidance Manual (PERG), based on a number of decisions by UK courts. Ultimately, whether an activity is carried on by way of business is a question of case-by-case analysis which takes into account several factors, including the degree of continuity, the existence of a commercial element, the scale of the activity, and the proportion the activity bears to other activities carried on by the same person but which are not regulated.
Cryptoasset regulation
There is currently no bespoke regime for cryptoassets and related activities. Whether a cryptoasset and related activities are regulated depends on whether the characteristics of the cryptoasset mean that it falls within the regulatory perimeter. To assist market participants, the FCA has published guidance on its approach, which sets out three broad categories of cryptoasset in relation to how they fit within existing FCA regulation:
At the time of writing, HM Treasury and the FCA have issued policy and discussion papers on the regulation of cryptoassets in the UK. HM Treasury has confirmed that it will introduce a regulatory regime for both stable tokens used as a means of payment, and for wider types of cryptoassets. The regulated category of stable tokens would refer to tokens which stabilize their value by referencing one or more assets, such as fiat currency or a commodity (i.e., stablecoins), and therefore could be reliably used for retail or wholesale transactions.
The UK government intends to take a phased approach to the regulation of cryptoassets and activities connected with cryptoassets. The regulation of fiat-backed stablecoin activities will take place in Phase 1. Activities relating to wider types of cryptoassets (including, for example, algorithmic stablecoins, and commodity-backed tokens not caught in Phase 1) will be in scope of Phase 2.
The stablecoin regime will apply to fiat-backed stablecoins only. This category will be defined in legislation – HM Treasury intends to capture those stablecoins which seek to maintain a stable value by reference to a fiat currency or basket of currencies, and hold (in whole or in part) that currency or basket as “backing”. This does not include algorithmic, crypto-backed or commodity-backed tokens — these tokens will be captured in Phase 2 (although the UK government does not at this stage intend to differentiate between those tokens and other unbacked cryptoassets in Phase 2).
HM Treasury intends to achieve the regulation of stablecoins through a mixture of amendments to the PSRs and the RAO to bring activities within the regulatory perimeter. The activities of issuance and custody of UK-issued fiat-backed stablecoin will be included in the RAO, enabling the FCA to make rules for firms conducting these activities. Firms wishing to apply for authorization to conduct either of the issuance or custody activities will be subject to FCA rules and guidance as is usual for FCA-regulated activities. The use of fiat-backed stablecoins in payment chains will be regulated through amendments to the payment services regime in the PSRs.
Until the wider regime for regulation of cryptoassets comes into place in Phase 2, the scope of the regime will not cover the activity of facilitating the exchange of cryptoassets (including stablecoins) for other assets — this will fall within the Phase 2 activity of “operating a cryptoasset trading venue”. However, exchange providers will still need to register with the FCA under, and comply with, the Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017 (MLRs) regime. This stablecoin regime will be adapted, rather than replaced, when the wider regime for the regulation of cryptoassets comes into place in Phase 2.
Whilst the regulators indicate in their roadmap that implementation of the stablecoin regime is anticipated to take place in 2025, no details have been provided on any implementation periods that may apply. Further details on the wider cryptoasset regime are expected to follow in due course.